From Classic to Contemporary: Models of Hiring and Selection

 

Resourcing the right people has always been essential for any organisation’s success. Over the years, the methods used to find and choose employees have changed and developed. Traditional approaches, which focused mainly on experience and followed a simple and gradual processes, are still used. However, newer approaches focus more on flexibility, understanding behaviour, and making sure right fit with the organization.

Past Experience

Human Capital Theory states that individuals build human capital (knowledge, skills, experience) over time. Past experience is seen as evidence of accumulated human capital, which should logically improve future productivity (Becker, 1964).

The direct entry pilot scheme in British Airways, requires qualified service pilots from the Army Air Corps, Royal Air Force, Royal Marines and Royal Navy who have completed their minimum service (British Airways, 2025).

One to One Interviews

According to the Trait Theory of Personality, One-to-one interviews often aim to assess personality traits (e.g., extraversion, conscientiousness). Trait theory suggests that stable personality traits can predict behavior and job performance. Interviewers try to gauge these traits through conversation (Allport, 1937).

The Nissan conducts first round interview with line manager at the Nissan's premises. This interview will assess the applicant's ability across the key selection criteria. Second round interview for shortlisted applicants will delve further into the complexity of the role and may include a workplace assessment, where the applicant will be given time to assess a case study and present their recommendations (Nissan Australia, 2025).

Task Oriented Matching

As per the Person-Job (P-J) Fit Theory, employees perform best when their abilities, knowledge, and skills match the demands of the job. Task-oriented matching is essentially a P-J fit approach because it focuses on matching candidates’ current skills to specific job tasks (Edwards, 1991).

Concerning the Microsoft Company, If advancing in the process, the next interview steps vary based on the role that the candidate applying for. It is to be prepared to demonstrate how the candidate meet the qualifications of the job by sharing specific examples from his or her past or ideas about how the candidate would accomplish a specific task. It is required to share how skills the candidates have gained throughout their career will translate to the role for which the candidate is interviewing. For some of Microsoft openings the candidate may be asked to write code, share a creative portfolio, or provide examples of him or her work in other ways (Microsoft, 2025).

Matching Attributes (Selection Paradigm)

Person – Organization Fit (P-O Fit) Theory focuses on the alignment between individual values, motivation, and beliefs and those of the organization. Here, predicts on increased retention, engagement and organizational citizenship behaviours (Chatman, 1989).

Hyundai Motor Group Innovation Center Singapore (HMGICS) invites that to join a purpose-driven team leading innovation and smart factory excellence to shape the future of mobility at HMGICS and beyond (Hyundai Motor Group, 2025).

Competency Based Assessment

Behavioural Event Interview (BEI) Theory is based on the idea that past behaviour in real situations predicts future behaviour. This forms the foundation for behavioural interviews used in competency based assessments. This directly links to key competencies like leadership, collaboration, and communication (McClelland, 1973).

People who enjoy doing their best, getting the best and being the best and who willing to look at challenges head on, inside out, or upside down to get the best possible results conforming to the highest ethical standards are Softlogic Holdings’ ideal picks. So, whether a candidate looking for an internship, graduate opportunities or a job opening to progress his or her professional career, at Softlogic she or he can shape his or her own path as they work with Softlogic global brands and the people who drive their sustainable business growth (Softlogic Holdings PLC, 2025).

Cultural Fit

As per Social Identity Theory (SIT), Individuals derive part of their self-concept from the groups to which they belong. People are more motivated and engaged when they identify with the organization or team. Employees who feel aligned with organizational culture (cultural fit) are more likely to identify with the group, enhancing cohesion and commitment (Tajfel & Turner, 1986).

Concerning HSBC, employees are expected to treat each other with respect, uphold ethical behaviour, and support a zero‑tolerance stance on discrimination, harassment, or bias (HSBC, 2025).

Ultimately, the traditional resourcing methods mainly focus on past experience, specific tasks, and standard interviews. Newer approaches go further, considering a person’s skills, qualities, and fit with the organization’s culture, as well as their potential for future growth. The best recruitment approach is combining both. It fills the role and also chooses people who can thrive and develop within the organization.


References:

Allport, G.W., 1937. Personality: A psychological interpretation. New York: Holt.

Becker, G.S. (1964) Human Capital: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis, with Special Reference to Education. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

British Airways (2025) Careers – Pilots. Available at: https://careers.ba.com/pilots (Accessed: 25 November 2025).

Chatman, J.A., 1989. Improving interactional organizational research: A model of person–organization fit. Academy of Management Review, 14(3), pp.333–349.

Edwards, J.R., 1991. Person-job fit: A conceptual integration, literature review, and methodological critique. International Review of Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 6, pp.283–357.

HSBC. (2025) Our culture | Inclusion at HSBC. Available at: https://www.hsbc.com/who-we-are/our-people/inclusion-at-hsbc/our-culture?utm_source (Accessed: 26 November 2025).

Hyundai Motor Group (n.d.) Our Culture | Careers | HMGICS, viewed 26 November 2025, https://www.hyundai.com/sg/careers/culture.

McClelland, D.C. (1973) Testing for competence rather than for intelligence. American Psychologist, 28(1), pp. 1–14.

Microsoft. (n.d.) Interview process and preparation tips. Available at: https://careers.microsoft.com/interview-process  (Accessed: 26 November 2025).

Nissan Australia (2025) Recruitment Process. Available at: https://www.nissan.com.au/about-nissan/careers-plus/recruitment-process.html (Accessed: 25 November 2025).

Softlogic Holdings PLC, 2025. Careers. Available at: https://www.softlogic.lk/careers?utm_source [Accessed 26 November 2025].

Tajfel, H. & Turner, J.C., 1986. The social identity theory of intergroup behavior. In: S. Worchel & W.G. Austin, eds. Psychology of intergroup relations. Chicago: Nelson-Hall, pp. 7–24.

Comments

  1. Harshaka De AbrewDecember 2, 2025 at 8:47 AM

    This is a great summary that effectively traces the evolution of resourcing from traditional to modern strategic approaches. This blog provides an excellent overview of how resourcing has evolved from simply assessing Past Experience (Human Capital Theory) to focusing on strategic fit. It correctly highlights the shift toward more reliable methods like Competency Based Assessment (Softlogic) and Matching Attributes based on Person Organization (P-O) Fit (Hyundai) crucial for predicting long term retention and engagement. By emphasizing the blend of traditional methods with advanced techniques to assess Cultural Fit and future potential. The blog affirms that the best resourcing drives both immediate performance and sustainable growth.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A R Saliya De Silva (E256160)December 4, 2025 at 5:42 PM

      I value your thoughtful comments and kind words very much. I am pleased that the post was helpful in tracing the evolution of resource management techniques. I totally agree that a more holistic approach that focuses on long-term potential and strategic fit is, indeed, a necessary ingredient for performance as well as growth, rather than mere experience-based assessments. It's interesting how combining traditional techniques with the more modern ones, like Cultural Fit and Competency Based Assessment, can truly optimize the hiring process and enhance overall organizational success.

      Delete
  2. Nadeesha DilrangiDecember 4, 2025 at 9:34 PM

    This is an excellent article. You have discussed how hiring and selection methods have evolved from traditional experience-based approaches to contemporary, holistic models. And also, you have discussed classical theories like human capital and trait theory with modern concepts such as person-job fit, person-organization fit, competency-based assessment, and cultural alignment, it illustrates how organizations today seek both immediate capability and long-term potential. Furthermore, you have discussed the examples from companies like British Airways, Microsoft, Hyundai, Softlogic, and HSBC reinforce how integrating past experience, skills, values, and cultural fit creates a more strategic and effective recruitment process.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A R Saliya De Silva (E256160)December 6, 2025 at 2:48 AM

      Thank you so much for your review Nadeesha! I'm glad to hear that the connections between the classical theories and the more modern hiring practices came through clearly. It’s true that organisations now have to balance both immediate capability and long-term potential, and the examples from companies like British Airways, Microsoft, Hyundai, Softlogic, and HSBC really show how these ideas play out in actual scenarios.

      Delete
  3. H.D.S.A.C.HETTIARACHCHIDecember 5, 2025 at 9:09 AM

    This piece gives a really good, clear look at how hiring has changed, going from old-school ways to what we do now. I like that it ties old ways, like interviews and putting people in roles based on skills, to ideas like Human Capital Theory and Person-Job Fit. It also points out newer methods that focus on what people are good at, fitting in with the company culture, and being a good fit for the organization. By bringing in Behavioral Event Interviews and Social Identity Theory, it shows that companies now care about skills and also things like keeping people happy, motivated, and aligned with the culture for a while. All in all, the post makes a great point that mixing old ways of checking experience with new, idea-based strategies helps companies hire better people.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A R Saliya De Silva (E256160)December 6, 2025 at 2:54 AM

      Thank you so much Sashini! I’m really glad the post resonated with you. My aim was to show exactly what you pointed out, that hiring has evolved from purely traditional methods into a more holistic approach that looks at skills, behaviour, and cultural alignment. It’s great to hear that the links between theories and actual practices came through clearly. Organisations today really do benefit from balancing both sides, the reliability of experience based methods and the insight that comes from understanding people more deeply through modern frameworks.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Employer Brand as a Strategic Driver for Resourcing and Management

Image
  In the ultra competitive modern day business environment, the workforce is unequivocally the decisive component that determines an organization's success or failure. This reality makes the fight for limited, high calibre talent more intense than ever. It's no longer enough just to have open roles; companies must possess a good employer brand the authentic, public perception of what it's like to work there to gain a critical competitive edge. A compelling employer brand is the ultimate advantage, not only acting as a powerful magnet to attract the very best candidates but also enabling an efficient recruitment process that saves significant time, reduces cost per-hire, and ensures the selection of the absolute right fit for the organization's long-term culture and goals. Strategic role in resourcing The primary benefit of a strong employer brand is its ability to create a clear competitive advantage in the war for talent. Attracting top talent According to ...
Read more

An Integrated Approach to Resourcing and Succession Planning

Image
  Employee talent is an organization’s most important and competitive asset. Sustaining growth and achieving long term success depends on having the right talent in the right roles at the right time. This necessity brings the Talent Management Pipeline into focus a systematic process to ensure standard flow of skilled and qualified individuals for the organization. The Talent Management Pipeline is a multi-staged system designed to identify, nurture and prepare employee for future roles, leadership and critical positions. Simply, a pool of candidates which is ready to fill a position. Identification and Sourcing Here, totally focuses on attracting and bringing talent to the organization. Briefly say strategic resourcing. According to the initiation of “Idea Nest” by Access Engineering PLC, the first of its kind in Sri Lanka providing staff members, undergraduate, and postgraduate students with a modern, vibrant working facility to empower them to work and develop innovative a...
Read more

Optimizing Organizational Capability Through Integrated Psychological Assessment

Image
  Psychological testing provides a data driven advantage for organizations in making better decisions on their work force. These kind of assessments offer objective insights into an individual’s potential, conduct and cognitive abilities. This information is critical for placing right person in right position and keeping the best employees while developing.  Psychological testing in an HR context. Psychological testing in an HR context is essentially the use of standardized, objective tools, such as structured surveys and timed exercises to measure a person’s inner qualities like their personality traits, aptitude and motivations that are not easily observed in an interview. The primary goal is to predict predict job success, helping HR professionals determine if a candidate has the required potential for growth and if their behavioural style will be a good cultural fit with the existing team and the organization’s environment, thereby reducing the faults on resourcing and i...
Read more